Maddy Moe’S Pizza Information

If you’re cruising through Butler, Tennessee, Maddy Moe’S Pizza at 142 Rainbolt St is one of those spots that instantly feels like a hometown favorite. From the moment you step inside, the casual, friendly vibe makes it clear this isn’t just about pizza-it’s about community. The menu leans into classic favorites with a few creative twists, offering everything from perfectly crisp, thin-crust slices to hearty, cheesy deep-dish pies that seem to vanish almost as soon as they hit the table. One standout has to be their signature combination pizzas, loaded with fresh toppings that manage to balance flavor without overwhelming the dough, and for those who like to mix it up, the customizable options let you craft a pie that hits exactly what you’re craving. Beyond pizza, their sides and appetizers are surprisingly solid, with garlic knots that are soft, buttery, and satisfyingly seasoned, and wings that come in a variety of sauces-spicy, tangy, or savory-each cooked just right to give that perfect bite without being greasy. Reviews often highlight how attentive and welcoming the staff are, keeping the pace brisk even on busier nights, which makes grabbing a quick slice or sitting down for a full meal equally enjoyable. The atmosphere has a relaxed, almost diner-like charm, with local sports memorabilia and simple décor that feels authentic rather than overdone, perfect for families, groups of friends, or solo visitors looking for a laid-back dining experience. Parking is straightforward, and the location on Rainbolt Street makes it an easy stop whether you’re heading downtown or just passing through town. Many diners also appreciate the consistent quality, noting that even on repeat visits, the crust maintains that ideal balance of chew and crisp, toppings stay fresh, and portion sizes leave you comfortably full without feeling overstuffed. If you’re a fan of casual, dependable pizza spots where flavor, service, and a friendly atmosphere all come together, Maddy Moe’S Pizza hits all the right notes.

Most Popular Dishes

  • House Salad $7.49
  • Side Salad $3.99
  • Chef Salad $10.99
  • Grilled Chicken Salad $10.99
  • Caesar Salad $7.49
  • Caesar Side Salad $3.99
  • Grilled Chicken Caesar Salad $10.99
  • 10" Cheese Pizza $7.99

Open Times

Monday Closed

Tuesday Closed

Wednesday 11:00 AM - 07:00 PM

Thursday 11:00 AM - 08:00 PM

Friday 11:00 AM - 08:00 PM

Saturday 11:00 AM - 08:00 PM

Sunday 12:00 PM - 07:00 PM

Icon

Location & Contact

Contact Details

  • 142 Rainbolt St, Butler, TN 37640, United States
  • Right Now :
  • +1 423-281-1159

What People's Say About Place

The man that owns Matty Moe‘s he is one of the nicest people I’ve ever met. He always has a good smile. It’s always very nice and his wife makes some of the best cheesecake but if you’re looking for portions that are worth paying for Maddie,Moes is the place to go Because you get what you pay for you get more than what you pay for they give you a wonderful portions I mean really good.

Our first time eating here and we were pleasantly surprised! The pizza was probably the best we've ever had! Very generous toppings and cooked to perfection! The perfect balance of flavors. It was ready when promised. The people are very friendly. The prices seem fair for the amount and quality of the food. We will definitely be back for more!

AMAZING! We had a great day at Watuga Pointe Recreation center and this pizza place was 7 minutes away. AND THE MEATLOVERS PIZZA IS AMAZINGG! They have real pizza oven and a good vibe. Thanks for making our lake day!!

Absolutely delicious!!! Great team! Convenient location! Lovely smiles! First time in there and we will be going back! What a blessing

Pizza was very very good I do say my only complaint was the pineapple tho I prefer chunks over shredded but it was still awesome will definitely be back

Wow! We were exploring the area and I saw the reviews for here and they did not disappoint! Everything scratch made! I had to try a meatball and it was delicious! I talked to the owner about it, all beef, gluten free so no bread, but you would never know it! It was so tender! The marinara is made in house and equally as good! My wife had the calzone and I ordered a white pie, we will have leftovers for dinner later. Can’t wait to come back! Oh, and grabbed an apple crisp cheesecake slice on the way out. If you are in the area, you won’t regret it!

Absolutely the best pizza we've had in years! We got a white pizza with spinach and mushrooms. The pie was huge, the crust was lightly crisp and buttery, and the toppings were fresh and fabulous! We highly recommend this place, and we plan on bringing the grandkids here when they come down for a visit, which we hope happens soon! Next time, I hope to leave room for a dessert, which sounded amazing too!

Best Pizza in Town, Hands Down! We took a whole crew of us—four adults and five kids—to Maddy Moe's Pizza, and they were just wonderful. They put tables together for us right away so our whole family could sit together, which we really appreciated. Now, let's talk about the pizza. It is, without a doubt, the best pizza in town. We got a special (a supreme) that was awesome and fed all the adults. My wife tried the margarita pizza and said it was amazing. The kids tore into their pepperoni and cheese pizzas. The one thing we all agreed on was that the crust was awesome—perfectly crispy and delicious. The menu is huge, and we're already planning our next trip back to try more. It's so great to have a spot like this that's perfect for a big family dinner. If you're looking for fantastic pizza, you have to go to Maddy Moe's!

Places Nearby